If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. You might also be interested in my sex podcast, Bedroom Radio. Thanks for visiting!
Character
by Taslima Nasrin
You’re a girl
and you’d better not forget
that when you step over the threshold of your house
men will look askance at you.
When you keep walking down the lane
men will follow you and whistle.
When you cross the lane and step onto the main road
men will revile you and call you a loose woman.
If you’ve got no character
you’ll turn back,
and if not
you’ll keep on going,
as you’re going now.
I read this poem with my students today and asked them to think about the phrase “loose woman”. They brainstormed synonyms on the board - promiscuous, slut. I asked them if it was a positive or negative phrase - negative, definitely. I asked them to read the poem again and imagine that “loose woman” was neutral and without any particularly loaded connotation.
They looked at me blankly.
I read it aloud another time.
“How did that feel? How is it different?”
More blank stares.
“What if a woman called herself ‘loose’? Does the phrase lose any power then?”
They would think that she was a slut and wonder about her character.
“What if all women looked at this phrase as neutral, then what?”
The promising one raises her hand and volunteers that the poem is irrelevant without that phrase being negative. That it defines the experience of the poem and the message.
I ask her what it would say about one’s character to not just ignore the insult but to refuse to see it as one? “What happens,” I ask, “to the second stanza when being a loose woman is neutral?”
But it isn’t neutral and my moment of instruction failed.
Why? Because I am a coward. The woman I reference, who doesn’t pass judgment on this term, who embraces it or at least tolerates it is only an abstraction to them. I deftly avoided the opportunity to out myself, and for that reason my question must have seemed nonsensical and without grounding.
Now, all I feel is a sense of mild shame. Here I have judged this room full of 18-year-olds as being prudish and judgemental when I, too, conform to this standard. Indeed, I am not the mythical loose woman. It is not neutral. But I’ve called myself out and I will keep walking so perhaps I’ve at least maintained my character.


If you've wondered what it would be like to get me on the phone, no need to wonder anymore!
(1.99/min.)



Posting tweet...
One Response for "loose women"
It is something central to the postmodern dilemma. We try to change the meanings of words instead of changing how we react to actions. Words take on connotations and that has value because complex words bring color to language. Asking people to see a word in different terms is as impossible as it is useless.
Whore means everything it has come to mean. If a person calls themselves a whore and then tells you the word doesn’t mean what they think it means then language has not succeeded.
At least that’s how I see it. There are a lot of words, neutering obscenity (even if it is well intentioned) makes dirty talk a lot harder.
I appreciate the comments but I think that you might have missed the point of the exercise. I wasn’t trying to convince my students that it is neutral rather to point out that it seems to be the message of the poem. I still feel like a hypocrite, though. - ellie
Next time try asking your students how they’d view the poem if it had been written about the same behavior in a man. Or better yet, have them re-write the poem entirely while making it about a man. If you want them to consider alternative points of view, I have found with most students in this day and age that you have to start by actually giving them one - and one they can wrap their TV/PSP addled minds around. (Being semi-humorous, here.) But I think you would have perhaps made your point better by pointing out that similar behavior in men is condoned, somewhat even encouraged - and yet women are condemned for it. Why?
Oh yes, that was quite part of the discussion. But I wanted to move past the cliched “double standard” cop-out. Another thing is that the double-standard discussion doesn’t even make sense in the context of that poem. The woman is called loose for even daring to leave her home and venture into the world. It isn’t even about sexual morality other than the ways that it is used to attack people. - ellie
You are so wonderful, Ellie! I adore your character!
Much love,
Always,
-R-
Trackbacks
Leave a reply